Net Zero 2050 is the global goal of balancing the greenhouse gases (GHGs) put into the atmosphere against those removed from it by the year 2050. It is the target the Paris Agreement sets for holding global warming to 1.5°C above pre-industrial levels. Almost nobody disputes that net zero is necessary. What is disputed is whether 2050 is achievable, and by what methods, and the arguments on each side have substance.

The case that it is feasible

Technology and cost

Solar and wind have fallen so far in cost that in many regions they now compete with fossil fuels or undercut them, and advances in battery storage are making renewable supply more reliable and easier to integrate into the grid. Demand is coming down at the same time. New building materials, smart grids and efficient appliances all cut consumption, and passive design takes a further slice off the energy a building needs for heating and cooling.

Carbon capture and storage (CCS) has moved from research into pilot projects, with some large-scale projects already operating; the technology captures emissions from industrial sources and stores them underground. Electric vehicles (EVs) are the other sign of momentum. The market is growing fast, better batteries are pushing ranges up and costs down, and governments are backing adoption with subsidies and charging infrastructure.

Policy

The Paris Agreement, and the climate commitments that numerous countries have made since, amount to a global consensus that net zero targets are needed. Beneath that, national and local governments are putting carbon pricing, renewable energy mandates and subsidies for green technology in place, which give businesses and individuals an economic reason to cut emissions. Companies are moving too. A growing number have set their own net zero targets under pressure from customers, investors and regulators, and their programmes typically run to renewable energy, energy efficiency and carbon offset projects.

The benefits on the way

The transition pays back as it goes. A green economy can create millions of jobs in renewable energy, energy efficiency and the other sustainable industries, which offsets the losses in the fossil fuel sectors. Burning less fossil fuel means cleaner air, fewer respiratory illnesses and lower healthcare costs. And a country that generates its own renewable power relies less on imported fossil fuels and has a more diverse energy supply, which is a gain for its energy security.

The case that it is not

Cost, grids and raw materials

CCS is promising but still expensive, and it is nowhere near deployed at the scale that would be needed. Capturing, transporting and storing CO2 all take energy, and the costs that come with that are substantial. The grid is a problem of its own: running on a high share of intermittent solar and wind puts its stability at risk, and keeping it stable needs significant investment in grid infrastructure and energy storage.

Then there is what the equipment is made of. Renewable technologies, batteries and the components around them need large quantities of rare earth metals and other materials, and that raises the same worries about supply constraints and environmental damage that we already have about fossil fuels.

Politics

Political will varies by country and by region, so policies and commitments are inconsistent, and a change of government can shift climate policy and undo the long-term planning and investment that followed the old one. Many economies and communities, particularly in less developed countries, depend on fossil fuels for both their energy and their jobs, and they can be expected to resist moving away from them. The target also asks a great deal of individuals: flying less, owning fewer cars, using more public transport. There is real scepticism about whether societies are willing or able to change on that scale.

Fairness between countries

Developing countries argue that emissions reductions have to be balanced against economic growth and the relief of poverty, and they have fewer resources to spend on green technology and infrastructure. The developed world reached its position largely by burning fossil fuels, so a developing country asked to sign up to global green policies before it has caught up economically, socially and in its infrastructure can understandably resist. The same history puts the greater responsibility for cutting emissions on the developed countries, and there are calls for them to fund and equip developing nations to reach net zero.

The timeline

The case against the date is that the current pace of emissions reductions is not enough to reach net zero by 2050, and that the immediate and drastic action that would change that will be hard to deliver politically and economically. The plans that do reach 2050 often lean on technologies that have not yet been proven at scale, such as advanced CCS and direct air capture, and relying on future breakthroughs strikes some as optimistic to the point of being risky.

Both cases deserve to be taken seriously. The technology and the policy are moving in the right direction; the politics, the fairness between countries and the reliance on unproven technology are the problems that still need answering, and they are what will decide whether 2050 holds.